Bethel fuel sales tax corrected

Ordinance 06-05, to amend the sales tax code to provide an exemption for senior citizens’ heating fuel, was finally passed on 2006 July 25. The vote was 4 to 2 and 1 abstention. For, Hugh Dyment, Tundy Rogers, Andy McGowen, Mary Kenick. Against, Thor Williams, Dan Leinberger. Abstain, citing conflict of interest, David Trantham.

The ordinance was originally submitted in February 2006 by Councilor Trantham and again by Councilor Rogers. Hearings occurred at the March 28, April 11, April 25, June 13, and July 25 council meetings. The delay in action was a result of examining the costs of modifying the exemption (by the finance committee) and the request by several councilors to have the ordinance re-written. The ordinance was not re-written and was finally voted upon.

The finance department estimated that perhaps 85 people would take advantage of the exemption. A limited ad hoc survey found elders can be paying $350 to $600 per month for 75 to 100 gallons (coldest months). The City might lose $14,700 in annual tax; seniors might save $173 per year.

It should be noted —

  • as the finance department notes, there are no data on who might use the exemption and how many gallons of fuel oil (diesel) would be involved
  • 75 to 100 gallons a month seems like a lot of fuel. The amount depends primarily on the quality of housing and heating. For older people who are enrolled tribal members, their tribe or tribal housing consortium has a trust responsibility to ensure adequate housing

The finance committee recommended unanimously against the ordinance because it might result in requests for special treatment or exemptions from other groups and individuals. Churches were used as a specific example. Therefore, correcting the fuel oversight would result in a drain on City finances.

Councilor Dyment promised to create an ordinance for the next council meeting, which would cut $24,000 from other City services because of the senior exemption.

It should also be noted —

  • the ordinance corrects an oversight in the existing municipal code which grants a recognition to older Bethel people, because they are older, and is not means tested
  • some, but not all, churches currently have a city government subsidy (reduced garbage fees).
  • sales tax income is not guaranteed income for budgeting purposes
  • as the price of fuel goes up, the number of gallons sold tends to decrease. Why cut $24,000?
  • this is not the first time that the elderly have been blamed for City deficits

Exemptions and subsidies do subtract from potential City income. As you can see below, elders’ exemptions are only R, S, and T of the alphabet list. There was no data presented as to the financial hit of senior exemptions out of the total exempted sales tax income. If the issue were one merely of tax income and city spending, then perhaps all exemptions should be revoked, not just the ones for older people.

Certainly, the illegal exemptions should be revoked first.
[ORDINANCE #04-28, AN ORDINANCE AMENDING SECTION 13.16.010 OF THE BETHEL MUNICIPAL CODE TO REMOVE CHURCHES FROM A MONTHLY FLAT RATE OF $45.00 TO A RESIDENTIAL SERVICE RATE WITH A FLAT RATE OF $12.00. Introduced by: City Manager Herron Date: November 30, 2004
Public Hearing: January 11, 2004, Action: Adopted
Vote: 4-2 (Rodgers, Dyment)
ENACTED THIS 11th DAY OF JANUARY, 2005 by a vote of 4 in favor and 2 opposed. Hugh Dyment, Mayor]

Initially, the Finance Director said eight churches would qualify; then eleven. But there are 16 announced places of worship in the newspaper. And there are other organizations with Federal tax exemptions as churches.

The Supreme Court has held that “[t]he First Amendment mandates governmental neutrality between religion and religion, and between religion and nonreligion.” Epperson v. Arkansas, 393 U.S. 97, 104 (1968).

This principle of neutrality “is part of our settled jurisprudence” and “prohibits government from abandoning secular purposes in order to put an imprimatur on one religion, or on religion as such, or to favor the adherents of any sect or religious organization. ” Texas Monthly, Inc. v. Bullock, 489 U.S. 1, 8-9 (1989) (plurality opinion) (quoting Gillette, 401 U.S. at 450). According to the text of the ordinance, the purpose for allowing churches to receive the same rates as residences for solid waste collection is that “churches are not like an ordinary business for profit” and “churches receive gifts and donations (not revenue), so Chapter 13.16.010 of the Code should charge churches with the lowest charge for solid waste services so as to treat churches fairly.”

Although government may provide a benefit to religious organizations without violating the Establishment Clause, the government must either provide this benefit to both religious and non-religious organizations that meet the same neutral criteria or the benefit must lift a substantial burden on the exercise of religion. Here, it is extremely unlikely that the commercial charge of $45 for solid waste collection places a substantial burden on the exercise of religion.

Thus, the ordinance can only be justified if it is extended to non-religious organizations as well. While it is true that residential dwellings receive the lower rate, if the city is going to extend the lower rate to churches, it should also extend the same rate to nonprofit organizations because the same rationale that was put forward for allowing churches to pay the lower rate (they do not have any revenue) would also apply to nonprofit organizations. Now, it may be the case that Bethel has no nonprofit organizations, which is why they were not included in the ordinance.

The Supreme Court has also held that providing a government benefit to one religious denomination while denying it to another constitutes an unconstitutional preference for one religion over others. See Bd. of Educ. v. Grumet, 512 U.S. 687, 706-07 (1994) (“whatever the limits of permissible legislative accommodations may be, it is clear that neutrality as among religions must be honored”).

Fuel oil sales tax was overlooked in the city codes which provide —

4.16.040 Exemptions.
R. The sale to a senior citizen of food intended for consumption by the senior citizen, his or her spouse living in the same household, or the unemancipated minor children of either the senior citizen or his or her spouse, who live in the same household. The senior citizen shall display at the time of the sale a current and valid senior citizen exemption certificate issued to the person under Section 4.16.050C of this chapter. For purposes of this subsection, “food” is defined in accordance with 7 U.S.C. 2012(g) (definition of “food” for purposes of the Food Stamp Act);
S. The payment of rent by a senior citizen on a single dwelling occupied as the senior citizen’s primary residence and permanent place of abode. The senior citizen shall provide proof at the time of payment of a current and valid senior citizen exemption certificate issued to the person under Section 4.16.050C of this chapter;
T. Payment for telephone, electric, water sewer utility services by a senior citizen on a single dwelling occupied as the senior citizen’s primary residence and permanent place of abode. The senior citizen shall provide proof at the time of payment of a current and valid senior citizen exemption certificate issued to the person under Section 4.16.050C of this chapter;

There is an additional credit —

13.16.070 Senior citizen credit.
A.
Any Bethel citizen at least sixty years of age residing in their own household shall receive up to a twenty-five-dollar monthly utility credit, if they are the primary source of income, after making application for such at the city utilities office.

B. All other Bethel citizens at least sixty years of age that do not meet the conditions of subsection A of this section shall receive up to a ten-dollar monthly utility credit after making application for such to the city utilities office.

C. Each residential unit shall be limited to one credit application. (Modification 2 of Ord. 85, 1980: prior code § 11.16.080)


Site Search Tags:
,
,
,
,
,
,

Advertisements

1 Response to “Bethel fuel sales tax corrected”



  1. 1 Separation of Church and State Day January 16 « O’Folks Trackback on 2007 January 16 at 8:17 pm
Comments are currently closed.



O’Folks (off their rocker)

Old age isn't a disease.

Arctic sunset

© header image

Comments how-tos

For those new to blogs, check out this post *commenting on blogs* Recent comments, on the sidebar blogroll, often have additional or complementary information. Recent revisions of posts themselves may be found by using the search box for "revised". Tech support says spam (ads or worse) is hitting WordPress heavily so if you don't see your comment in 24 hours, send an E-mail and TS will check the spam trap.

RSS BHIC Bringing Health Info to the Community

  • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.

Categories

RSS Nonagenarian news

  • WWII vet who led 'Reunion of Honor' tours dies at age 95 - USA TODAY
    USA TODAYWWII vet who led 'Reunion of Honor' tours dies at age 95USA TODAYTALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Marine Lt. Gen. Lawrence F. Snowden, who fought in the battle of Iwo Jima and led reconciliation reunions to the Pacific island in retirement, died Saturday — a day before the 72nd anniversary of the famous fight's opening salvos.Lt. Gen. Lawrence Sno […]
  • Bob Michel, House GOP Statesman Across Five Decades, Dies at Age 93 - The Weekly Standard
    WREX-TVBob Michel, House GOP Statesman Across Five Decades, Dies at Age 93The Weekly StandardBob Michel, the former Republican minority leader in the House of Representatives, passed away February 17, a few days short of his 94th birthday. House Republicans were in the minority for the entire 38 years of Michel's career, and in some people's ...For […]
  • Lorraine Geis, age 95 - New Prague Times
    Lorraine Geis, age 95New Prague TimesLorraine S. Geis, age 95, of Shakopee, entered eternal life on Sunday, February 19, 2017, at her home in Shakopee. Visitation will be Tuesday, February 21, 2017, from 4-7 PM, and Wednesday from 9:30-10:30 AM, both at McNearney-Schmidt Funeral and ...
  • Mr. A. J. Kent, age 93, of Rome | Coosa Valley News - Coosa Valley News
    Mr. A. J. Kent, age 93, of Rome | Coosa Valley NewsCoosa Valley NewsMr. A. J. Kent, age 93, of Rome, passed away on Saturday, February 18, 2017, at a local hospital. Mr. Kent was born in Piedmont, Alabama on June 29, 1923, ...and more »
  • Wilfred Woods, Wenatchee World publisher, dies at age 97 - seattlepi.com
    seattlepi.comWilfred Woods, Wenatchee World publisher, dies at age 97seattlepi.comThe two guiding philanthropists behind Snowy Owl Theater, beautifully situated in the Icicle Canyon outside Leavenworth, doubtless voted differently in the 2012 election. Harriet Bullitt, of the family who founded KING Broadcasting, is an ...and more »
  • Twin Peaks star Warren Frost, who played Doc Hayward, dies age 91 - Digital Spy
    Digital SpyTwin Peaks star Warren Frost, who played Doc Hayward, dies age 91Digital SpyHe was best known for his role as Doc Hayward in Twin Peaks, as well as Susan's father in Seinfeld and also as a doctor in Psycho IV: The Beginning. His children are Twin Peaks co-creator Mark Frost, The Ring and As the World Turns actress Lindsay ...
  • Cooking the Ultimate Prime Rib in 90-Day Aged Beef Fat - Eater
    EaterCooking the Ultimate Prime Rib in 90-Day Aged Beef FatEaterSmookler loves dry-aged prime rib, but he doesn't think other chefs have taken it far enough. His goal is to create the ultimate prime rib experience. According to him, when a piece of meat has been aged 45 to 90 days, “the flavor components aren't ...
  • New York Man Who Completed 744 Marathons Dies at Age 96 - ABC News
    New York Man Who Completed 744 Marathons Dies at Age 96ABC NewsFILE - In this Nov. 14, 2010 file photo, Don McNelly (90), of Irondequoit, N.Y., competes in the 2010 Harrisburg Marathon in Harrisburg, Pa. McNelly, an internationally known runner who completed 744 marathons has died, he was 96. The Richard H. Keenan ...and more »
  • 'Extraordinary' UNCP alum dies at age 90 - The Robesonian
    The Robesonian'Extraordinary' UNCP alum dies at age 90The Robesonian10 in Charlotte. He was 90. “While we mourn the loss of Jesse Oxendine, we celebrate his extraordinary life and service to our nation and UNC Pembroke,” said Chancellor Robin Gary Cummings. “He helped lay the foundation for our thriving football ...St. Pauls Review | A Robeson Coun […]
  • MAHONEY: Writing the book on peace — at age 96 - Hamilton Spectator
    Hamilton SpectatorMAHONEY: Writing the book on peace — at age 96Hamilton Spectator"The young have a natural sense of fairness," Ray says to me, and his eyes, still bright with that original vision, seem (like much about him) a corridor to all the ages he's been, to the nearness of the lad he was, keeping the man he is always young ...
July 2006
M T W T F S S
« Jun   Aug »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  

Haeremai Camai Bula Bepuwave Bienvenidos

  • 154,997 visitors

%d bloggers like this: